Showing posts with label the sad bear. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the sad bear. Show all posts

Thursday, October 28, 2010

Daniel Silliman on Ambition, the Age of Adz

As you probably already know, a few weeks ago I contributed a Sufjan song to a mid-week mix, which sparked a few questions, which prompted me to write this thing.


In all honesty, I mostly responded to Tony's question about Sufjan's general appeal. I hedged around Silliman's inquiry about The Age of Adz, trying to put the album in perspective, but I didn't address his question head on.

Well, I probably should have asked why Silliman was disappointed. He has written on his disappointment with Adz over at The The Poetry Blog (<--not a typo). An excerpt:
Which is why, and I know I’ve come here the long way round, I’m disappointed with Sufjan Stevens. This album he’s released, Age of Adz, is not a bad album. It’s not. But it marks, for Stevens, an abandonment of a project that was Whitmanian in its ambition, that was, like Leaves of Grass and Moby-Dick, an ambitious attempt to put a whole country into a work of art. There are not a lot of efforts on this scale, but Stevens, this indie musician who was known, at one point, for wearing wings in concert and signing surprisingly religious songs, started something with his “Fifty States Project.”
The post is titled "Trying to do something important: a couple of thoughts on ambition in a work of art," and it's definitely worth your time. While Silliman's thoughts do not diminished my ever-growing appreciation for Adz, it certainly has made me rethink my rather casual shrugging-off of the end of the Fifty States Project.

[I plan, by the way, to explain my appreciation for Adz more in depth in my 2010 albums post (is it a spoiler that Adz is going to make the cut?).]

Go read it.

---

I am not convinced that Sufjan is completely finished with states. I don't doubt that he never seriously intended to create fifty albums on the scale of Michigan and Illinois. The promotion may have been gimmicky, but the two albums were not. Sufjan need not pretend to have 48 more albums up his sleeve in order to tackle one more, or a few more, or a dozen more.

Sufjan seems in, or perhaps at the other end of, a rather dark period of discouragement and serious health issues. I imagine some of his cynicism over the project (and, I gather, his entire sound, really) will fade. He's not pop-music young, but he is only 35. I don't see him as someone who fades away, or stops making good music in middle age. He has, I surely hope, decades of music-making yet in him. He interrupted the project for Seven Swans, and perhaps he will resume states in future.

I think the main thing to get out of all of this is that Sufjan, like everyone else, needs to leave New York City.

Sunday, October 17, 2010

On Sufjan

My contribution to this past week's Mid-Week Mix at the Sad Bear drew a lot of discussion, including two requests to explain why I like Sufjan Stevens in general, and why I think Adz is great too. Rather than try to do that in a few sentences or paragraphs, I wrote a rather expansive guest post explaining/considering/defending the appeal of Sufjan. It's long but to the point and not, I don't think, repetitive. Please go read it. Comment over there (or here if you'd rather). Let me know what you think. Am I wrong? Did I miss something?

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Mid-Week Mixes are back.

Loyal readers may recall that I was a guest contributor on #004 in the Sad Bear's Mid-Week Mixes series back in February. And if you follow the Sad Bear, which you probably should, you'll know that the mid-week mix has been mostly on hiatus since June.

Well, it's back, and I've been asked to be a regular contributor. I'm pleased, and I think this week's mix, #026, is great. Go check it out.

Anyway, I need to hop in the shower and eat dinner before seeing Owen Pallett and the National at the Rialto tonight. I'm pumped.

Thursday, September 23, 2010

Humbert Humbert and Understanding

"The leap from disgust to understanding is a big one, but moving from understanding to liking feels the most natural thing in the world."

Chris wrote this in the comments of a post Jon wrote over at the sad bear a few days ago about a Clockwork Orange.

Jon specifically talked about the tendency of audiences to think Stanley Kubrick was celebrating Alex, the protagonist. After tying in Dexter and suggesting that making a serial killer likable is not really a great feat, he concludes, "What's great is to demonstrate that the fact that the worst about us can seem likable should be shocking."

This is quite good. It's not so weird that we like terrible things or people. Anti-heroes are old hack, really. What would be really great today would be an effective reminder that this should be shocking, that Dexter, for example, should be more shocking than it is.

Tony then drew the natural connection to Lolita and the frighteningly charming Humbert Humbert, which led to Chris' comment, which in turn led to this post.

Chris is completely right, you know. Understanding involves a recognition of shared humanity, so to condemn something you understand is to condemn yourself. And most of us would rather excuse than condemn ourselves, so we almost instinctively excuse what we understand.

Thus the desire not to understand evil is common in places and generally unspoken, but sometimes quite explicit. Some even think that one must not--must not!--understand evil. The most strident of moral condemnation usually relies on not understanding, and there's a kind of chosen ignorance at the core of hatred. If you want to condemn and to hate, in other words, you have to keep understanding at bay.

This may be one reason why the academic humanities tend to be liberal or pluralistic or amoral (rather than immoral). If the goal is to understand (as it certainly is with history), and if you cannot easily keep any distance between understanding and approval, then it's simply natural to excuse or explain away pretty much everything. Letting understanding and approval drift into one indistinguishable blur is easy.

But of course this doesn't really work much better than self-prescribed ignorance, does it? Just about everything under the sun is understandable, but there's plenty that's simply inexcusable. Humbert Humbert, for instance.